Big games involve big moments. And big moments require bold decisions.
No games are bigger in American soccer than the MLS Cup playoffs, and with the Chicago Fire set to embark on their second consecutive playoff journey, all coaches, players, and fans must be prepared for anything.
One such possibility has to be examined: penalty kicks. In the best-of-three first round, tied games go directly to a shootout without extra time. This happened to the Fire last season when their meeting with the Philadelphia Union ended 2-2, with Jack Elliott and Joel Waterman both missing their kicks to hand the Fire a Game 1 loss.
In shootouts, even the tiniest factor could change the outcome. So if the Fire do get drawn into one against Charlotte FC this week, they’ll want all the help they can get.
Chris Brady has been the Fire’s star in goal over the last four years. He has grown year after year and played his way into the U.S. Men’s National Team picture. Although he’s kept the Men in Red in so many games, there is one area he hasn't excelled in: facing penalties.

Since 2022, Brady has faced 76 penalty kicks. He’s saved eight. His 11.3% on-target save rate is incredibly low for a goalkeeper of his quality, and it’s not exactly clear why. The 22-year-old is one of the best shot-stoppers in the league, but has only saved two penalties in his MLS career (and one saw the rebound instantly tapped in by Djordje Mihailovic). Three of his eight career saves came against Rochester NY FC in 2022 in MLS Next Pro, a team that has not existed since that season.